1. Chat

Do You Prefer Self-Scan or Manned Checkouts in a Supermarket?

Ask a Question

More and more stores are introducing self scan, checkouts and even scan as you go. Do you prefer these, or do you still like to use a manned check out?

Personally, I love being able to walk into my Sainsbury's, armed with just my iPhone, I have the Sainsbury's scanning app on there so can go round picking up everything I want, scanning it and packing it straight into my shopping bags. I then smugly walk past all the frustrated-looking people waiting in long queues for manned tills to get to the self-scan checkout where I simply scan the QR code to transfer my shop to their system and then pay by Apple Pay. It's so much simpler and quicker. I love it!

TractorGirl327
a year ago
What do you think of this?+20 points
Advertisement
Lynibis

I would just like someone to prove to me how these unmanned systems work without letting people cheat and steal stuff. Someone said they do random checks, well how many, one in a hundred, 2 or 3? Surely a random check would be embarrassing for those who are honest. What they save on staff must surely go in shoplifting. I will NEVER use either method and prefer to be served by a flesh and blood human, not a machine!

Like
Reply5
TractorGirl327

Lynibis But even people who use a manned checkout could hide something in their coat, pram or bag and not pay for it.

Although if someone was going to steal something they probably wouldn't go through a checkout at all, whether it was manned or unmanned. They'd just walk out with it!

More and more self-scan tills now have cameras and they can see exactly what you're scanning and what you aren't.

As I said, I much prefer to self scan. I've had a few random checks and they check 5 items from your bag to see if it's been scanned. It's not embarrassing at all and for the few times it happens (twice in the last 6 months maybe?) it's worth it to walk past you in a long queue and be done, paid and in my car driving home before you've even unloaded your trolley.

Like
Reply
Pjran

I prefer the scan as you go handheld machines so you can pack as you go. It’s never a problem if an item doesn’t scan as there’s always help at the checkout.

Like
Reply3
ch7leach

I'm with you here, in 90% of cases I use a scanner and it works really well, also seems to be quicker getting through and I hate standing in queues. I have randomly been checked a good few times and it's always been perfect other than waiting for a staff member to come along and do it.

Like
Reply2
Pjran

ch7leach ah yes the random checks forgot about that because I can’t remember the last time that happened. Pre pandemic I think.

Like
Reply1
ch7leach

Yeah it's been a while since I have had one, when it happens it's usually the 5 item check, only once have I had a full scan

Like
Reply1
boepeep

I think self checkouts are excellent for people who aren't very good interacting with others. Social anxiety is a thing. I have it myself, so I know how beneficial they are for people like myself.

Like
Reply4
Lynibis

boepeep I really can see your point but the more you disconnect from people the worse it will become. I have always chatted to check out folk, without holding up the queue, and never had a rude one. Take tiny steps just saying hello with a smile could be beneficial to both parties.

I worry this world is becoming so disconnected from each other what with online shopping, gaming, social media, we are heading for a very lonely old age.

Like
Reply3
boepeep

Lynibis I see your point to. I've had this for 12 years. I'm 24 now. So when self checkouts became a thing , there was a sigh of relief. Saying that, I'm all for manned checkouts. To each their own.

Like
Reply2
Pjran

boepeep absolutely, you do what’s best for you. Only you know how it affects you.

Like
Reply1
eyeballkerry

I think someone put a very funny tik tok video online about how the person buying and using these machines has never had any training so if by ‘accident’ they do not scan an item but leave the shop it is not their fault.

Like
Reply
Jerseydrew

Self scan. Supermarkets are too peoplely if I can avoid them I weill do.

Like
Reply1
Midnightflower

I like having both as a option. Self service is great if your in a hurry and just buying a few items, but I wouldn't want to scan a large shop myself.

Like
Reply1
Nadiaparveen

Self checkout as it's so much faster and convenient.

Like
Reply1
JLouM

I prefer to use a checkout with a person. It keeps them in a job and it’s also useful for them to deal with problems there and then and know what the problem is. The self-scan machines always jump or time out or don’t accept the money. I find them more frustrating.

Like
Reply4
Sammycb

I much prefer a manned checkout. I always feel so flustered when using the self checkouts plus everytime I've used one I've had to get assistance from a staff member 😊

Like
Reply2
jam45

I use both. Today I used the self-service till and forgotten to take my £5 change. An Asda self-service staff came up to me and told me I left it in the "change till". The supermarkets have the latest technology and can spot attempt theft, etc.

Like
Reply1
stuartsmith544

I will unless the queues are crazy I will always use a manned checkout as if people do the self scan then eventually the company will consign the manned checkouts to the history books and I dread to think what the members of staff will do in terms will the companies get rid of them .

Like
Reply
hspexy

I’m fine with self service - that way I can check the discounts/reductions have been applied

Like
Reply1
chlobo85

As a anxious person I love them it means if I'm not feeling up to it I don't have to communicate with anyone

Like
Reply
HEDGEHOGS

I use self scan tills or scan and bag as I go around the shop, nice and quick.

Like
Reply
Deansmum

I prefer the manned tills especially for my big shops. Occasionally if I'm in a rush after work I'll use the self checkout but do try to use the manned till then.

Like
Reply1
SueGeorge22

Every self scan means one less manned checkout. Less staff less jobs. Our children and grandchildren will need to earn money at some time in their lives so where are the jobs going to be????? Having worked in a large supermarket I am totally against self scan checkouts

Like
Reply5
TractorGirl327

I don’t agree about less jobs. People have to design the self-scan machines. Build them. Install them. Maintain them. Clean them. Self scan frees up staff that used to work on checkouts to be available to do other things - take in deliveries, restock shelves, help customers in the store etc. Customer’s time is valuable and if we can save 10 minutes in the supermarket well, as they say, time is money.

Like
Reply
darlingfarmhous

The best thing about self scanning, is that you don’t have to deal with the ever increasing situation of staff wearing headsets. They have them in our local Morrisons and now in B&Q.. the staff wearing them are conversing with other staff members instead of focussing on the customer in front of them. This week I have experienced 2 situations where I was unnecessarily delayed or shouted at by a member of staff because I responded to the conversation they were having on headsets. They are the worse thing that stores have done. Give me a robot any day of the week!

Like
Reply
melaniecrank

Self serve all the time

Like
Reply
tonygch96

Self Service is not very convenient for disabled people

Like
Reply3
Deansmum

tonygch96 or the elderly that live alone. Sometimes the checkout operator is the only person they talk to all day/week

Like
Reply
tonygch96

Very true and some are both disabled and elderly, but again it is one of the days interaction with people.

Like
Reply
RainbowY

Always prefer a human at the till. If I have to use a self scan a member of staff usually has to rescue me anyway

Like
Reply2
Carrymehome58

I will not go into my local Matalan anymore the card payment till is selfservice .how ridiculous in a clothes shop tried once that was enough !!!

Like
Reply
Latefran

I haven't got a smart phone so can't use a scanning app. Now that there are very few checkouts open I feel I am being forced down the self service route. I pay enough for my groceries already so don't want to do the job of a till person unpaid. It was also nice to interact with the person serving you it seems such an uncustomer friendly experience now.

Like
Reply1
stephward01

I refuse to use them. I want staff with the personal touch there. Not machines or robots. AI, used to save shops money and not jobs. That's the way I see it.

Like
Reply2
barbarabanks300

I like the scan as you go then you can pack at the same time and check the price as well .

If they do check your shopping they only do about 5 items

Like
Reply1
ChellJudge4790

I prefer self scan with my sainsburys card I love the discounts . Been checked a couple of times when they scan so many items which is no big deal , I'm not doing anything wrong so all good even when I've set alarms off a few times when I've left a store I have all my receipts so no biggie saves time and since I'm not a people person it saves my anxiety levels

Like
Reply1
ChrisInMakati

I like the Amazon supermarkets where there are no checkouts at all. You just take what you need off the shelves and walk out the door. The system charges your card for what you've had. Tesco is trialing a similar system in a couple of their stores too.

Like
Reply1
Jerseydrew

Oh id like that even easier

Like
Reply
AnnMccriss36263

I prefer manned checkouts. It's nice to interact with a human. Think of all those staff members who will lose their jobs if supermarkets only have self scanners. I hate using them...

Like
Reply3
Lolly1967

I prefer manned checkouts for 2 reasons....

1, I am physically disabled and use a tri-walker, which builds up large amounts static electricity in myself for some odd reason.... This ALWAYS causes the self scan machines to go wrong and I am constantly needing an assistant.

2, I personally like dealing with a person at manned checkouts, and I would hate to have to use a store with all self scan ones. Too many places are pushing self scan on us already. Keep the human interaction and people's jobs....xx

Like
Reply1
smartie67

i don't mind either, its nice to have the choice.

Like
Reply
doreenphilpit

I dont like them , it always goes wrong and it’s putting people out of work , they always have an assistant hanging around to help they could be on a till where they are needed .

Like
Reply1
TravisWarden

Manned please.

Like
Reply
lauragoodenough

they check your bags in aldi before they start scanning your shop in asda i like scan and go because you see how much you are spending it’s easy to keep to a budget to i been checked a few times in asda they check five random items

Like
Reply
marlene6835

Preferred to be served by a cashier

Like
Reply1
Amylou88

I prefer some one serving me when I have done a big shop but if I only have a basket I always go to self scan I don't mind them.

Like
Reply
tumblespots

I prefer a cashier. Have you ever thought about how many people's grubby hands have been all over the self-scan tills?! Have you ever seen anyone wipe/clean them?

Like
Reply1
misstrace125570

Manual, because if everyone chooses self checkout, there wont be any more tills or jobs. Self checkout is better for just a few things to avoid the queue. I struggle with checkout because of illness. Its better to have someone to help with packing too.

Like
Reply1
tracy5mith

I personally refuse to use self service tills. I am very capable to use them but it is taking away other peoples jobs. I don’t work there and I don’t get paid to scan my products. This also means they are saving on wages and making more profit on everyones shopping. I also like the personal touch and conversation from a human being. People need to think of others and although people may find it quicker to use the self scan it could affect the next generations for jobs including your own family or even yourself!

Like
Reply
KarenMassey

I prefer self scanned or the handset as then you can see the prices at each stage. too many times the checkout assistant has overcharged and then I have to query with customer service.

Like
Reply
jaineyjaine

Absolute nightmare. Fed up of having to wait for someone to come and ok your bags, your alcohol and the tags on your clothes. Scan and go is great but the self scanners are a nightmare. Asda leaves a lot to be desired.Worst shop.

Like
Reply
One of the UK's largest deal hunting communities

Join for free to get genuine deals, money saving advice and help from our friendly community

Tom Church
Co-Founder &
Chief Bargain Hunter
Tom Church, Co-Founder
Want deals & discounts automatically?
+100 bonus points!
Latest Deals Browser Extension
Latest Deals Mobile App
  • Download our app
  • 1,000+ new deals every day
  • Earn free Amazon vouchers
  • Daily deal alerts - never miss the best offers!
  • Download the Latest Deals iOS AppDownload the Latest Deals Android App
Latest Deals
Disclaimer

The content on Latest Deals is a combination of information submitted by members of the public and the Latest Deals team. Whilst we make every effort to try and ensure genuine, accurate content we cannot guarantee it. Please always carry out your own due diligence and double check the details of an offer on the retailer's own website.

How this site works
  • To cover the site's running costs, Latest Deals uses affiliate links.
  • If you click on a link to an external website and make a purchase, Latest Deals may earn a commission.
  • We allow deals to be shared on Latest Deals irrelevant of whether or not they generate us money. Our #1 concern is helping you save money.
  • If you have any questions about how the site works, drop us a message. We're always happy to help.
Copyright © 2024 Latest Deals Limited
Registered in England and Wales. Company number 10286141. 124 City Road, London, England, EC1V 2NX